Cover : The Protection of Kurds by the CNDA

The Protection of Kurds by the CNDA

Legal Background

Protection is granted on the basis of well-defined criteria, in particular a fear of persecution on grounds of race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political opinion, in accordance with the provisions of the Geneva Convention.(1)

The CNDA (Cour nationale du droit d'asile, National Court of Asylum) examines asylum applications against strict criteria, assessing credibility and the risk of persecution. Kurdish applicants face particular challenges, which call for an in-depth understanding of the political and ethnic context. They are often caught up in political and ethnic conflicts in their countries of origin and may face various forms of persecution linked to their ethnic identity, their political opinions or their involvement in political activities.

Focus on the Protection of Kurdish Conscientious Objectors

The CNDA's decision of 7 June 2022, no. 21042074, marks a turning point in the assessment of asylum applications based on conscientious objection to military service.(2)

The CNDA draws on international sources, in particular United Nations Commission on Human Rights resolution no. 1998/77 of 2 April 1998 (3) and the case law of the European Court of Human Rights (see ECtHR, 7 July 2011, no. 23459/03), which recognise conscientious objection as a fundamental right linked to deeply held personal convictions.

According to the CNDA, conscientious objection to military service is defined as a genuine personal conviction, of a proven degree of strength, coherence and seriousness for the person concerned. This definition underlines the importance of assessing each case on the basis of the sincerity and depth of the applicant's convictions.

For Kurds, conscientious objection may constitute legitimate grounds for an asylum application. However, demonstrating the sincerity and depth of their personal conviction can be a major challenge, requiring a careful legal approach and the gathering of substantial evidence.

The Role of the Lawyer

An asylum lawyer must not only understand these criteria but also know how to apply them specifically to Kurdish cases. This involves preparing detailed files, presenting tangible evidence and setting out persuasive legal arguments in support of the asylum application. The lawyer must build a strong case, presenting compelling evidence and testimony. Legal representation includes preparing for the hearing, supporting the client and formulating appropriate legal arguments.

Conclusion

These experiences reaffirm the vital role of the asylum lawyer, not only as a defender of individual rights but also as a contributor to justice and to the protection of vulnerable people. Our commitment as lawyers is essential in navigating the legal maze of asylum and thus ensuring that justice is done.

We hope you have found this article useful. The practice is available to discuss your personal situation and to work with you to find practical and effective answers. Please do not hesitate to contact us.

Recent publications