What place does pregnancy denial (déni de grossesse) have in French law? Court cases reported in the press over the last ten years have brought this long-standing phenomenon to light. This article examines the legal issues raised by pregnancy denial, in particular the criminal responsibility of a mother who commits infanticide.
Death may occur accidentally, through lack of care, as a result of a head injury or following an act by the mother. According to the child psychiatrist Dr Dayan, the vast majority of pregnancy denials are not followed by any harmful act; he estimates that fewer than 1% of pregnancy denials are followed by infanticide (1).
What Is Pregnancy Denial?
Pregnancy denial can be defined as being unaware of one's own pregnancy. It may last only a few months or the entire pregnancy, up to the birth.
In France, studies estimate that there are 1 to 3 cases of pregnancy denial per 1,000 births each year, affecting between 800 and 2,000 women a year (2).
Traditionally, pregnancy denial was thought more likely to occur in women who were young, disadvantaged, had intellectual or educational difficulties, used drugs or had psychiatric problems.
However, since the 2000s, studies have shown that there is no “typical” profile for pregnancy denial; most of the women studied were in good social circumstances.
Infanticide, Neonaticide, Filicide
In public health, the term “infanticide” refers to a woman killing her child within 76 hours of giving birth. The term “neonaticide” is used for the deaths of children occurring in the year of their birth. Finally, after the age of 1, the term “filicide” is used, meaning the killing of one's own child.
The specific offence of infanticide appeared in Article 300 of the former Criminal Code, defined as the “murder or premeditated murder of a newborn child, committed before the expiry of the three-day period for registering the newborn with the civil registry”. Note that under the Vichy regime, these crimes were tried in the criminal court (tribunal correctionnel), without a jury.
Since 1994, infanticide is no longer mentioned in the Code pénal (French Criminal Code) as a specific crime; it falls within the general category of homicide of a minor under 15.
Several criminal offences may apply when pregnancy denial has a tragic outcome, all of which aim to protect human life. Article 221-4 of the same code provides for a sentence of life imprisonment (réclusion criminelle à perpétuité) for murder committed against a minor under 15. No distinction is made between a person who is a few hours, a few months or 14 years old.
The material element of the offence consists of a positive act. Here it is particularly important for the lawyer handling the case to examine the forensic medical reports used to establish the cause of death, any signs of blows, and so on. It is possible to submit observations following an expert report or to request a second expert opinion. If no such act is established, a charge more consistent with the facts, such as negligence, will be brought.
The question of intent is the greatest difficulty with this offence. The public prosecutor must prove the intention to kill. For this, the perpetrator must have been in full possession of their free will.
It is through the lens of criminal law that the issue of pregnancy denial has resurfaced in the media over the last ten years.
- The Véronique Courjault case: on 18 June 2009, she was sentenced to 8 years' imprisonment for the murder of her 3 newborn babies, in 1999 in France and in 2002 and 2003 in South Korea.
- The Dominique Cottrez case: on 29 July 2010, she was sentenced to 9 years in prison for the murder of her eight newborn children, following legal debate over whether the offences were time-barred.
- The Céline Lesage case: in March 2010, she was sentenced to 15 years' imprisonment for the murder of her six newborn babies found in a cellar in Valognes. The mother admitted killing them between 2000 and 2007.
- The Ramona Canete case: on 23 March 2018, she was sentenced to 8 years in prison for the murder of five of her children at birth between 2009 and 2015.
- The Fabienne Kabou case: she was sentenced on appeal to 15 years in prison for killing her 15-month-old daughter Adélaïde. At her first trial in June 2016, the Assize Court (cour d'assises) had sentenced her to 20 years' imprisonment.
- The Fiona case: little Fiona's mother, Cécile Bourgeon, was sentenced on appeal on 11 February 2018, together with the girl's stepfather, to 20 years' imprisonment. They were found guilty of intentional violence resulting in unintended death against a minor under 15. At a first trial, Cécile Bourgeon had been acquitted on the main charge but was sentenced to five years in prison for failing to assist a person in danger, tampering with a crime scene and making a false report of a crime.
Even though the maximum sentence is life imprisonment, the sentences handed down by the Assize Courts are comparatively very low. This is because in these cases the jury very often opted for diminished responsibility owing to the impaired judgement of the mothers who committed infanticide.
Criminal Responsibility of the Mother
The rule is laid down in Article 122-1 of the Criminal Code, which distinguishes between:
- cases where the person suffers from a disorder that has abolished their judgement (discernement), in which case the person is not legally responsible for their actions;
- and cases where the person's judgement has been impaired by a psychological disorder, in which case the court simply takes this circumstance into account when determining the sentence.
Yet most of the scientific literature on pregnancy denial refers to the woman being in “a state of shock” (sidération) at the time of giving birth. Current case law of the French Assize Courts shows that this state of shock is a disorder that “[only] impaired her judgement or hindered the control of her actions”. The mothers are therefore considered responsible and face a sentence.
The mother's mental state at the time of birth is not regarded as a factor that automatically reduces her responsibility (with exceptions, such as total denial with a recognised psychotic state).
It is vital to have proper legal support for issues of this kind. This is a complex subject in which the analysis of psychological, psychiatric and medical evidence is crucial. The firm is at your disposal to discuss your personal situation and work with you to find concrete and effective answers to your problem; please do not hesitate to contact us.



