Cover : NEWS – Minors and Voluntary Police Interviews

NEWS – Minors and Voluntary Police Interviews

The Constitutional Council as guardian of the protection of minors: the regime for voluntary police interviews of minors held to be entirely unconstitutional!

Cass. crim., 27 November 2018, no. 18-90.026

Constitutional Council, decision of 8 February 2019, no. 2018-762 QPC

Reminder: a voluntary interview (audition libre) allows investigators to question a person suspected of having committed or attempted to commit an offence, without placing them in police custody (garde à vue). If you are questioned in a voluntary interview, you have the right to leave at any time.

On 27 November 2018, in a judgment of its Criminal Chamber, the Cour de cassation (French Supreme Court) ruled on a priority question of constitutionality (question prioritaire de constitutionnalité, QPC) concerning the provisions of Article 61-1 of the Code de procédure pénale (French Code of Criminal Procedure), which sets out the regime for the voluntary interview of a minor or an adult.

Article 61-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, introduced by Law no. 2014-535 of 27 May 2014, provides that a minor in respect of whom there are plausible grounds to suspect that they have committed or attempted to commit an offence may be questioned in a voluntary interview.

On reading this article, it is clear that the legislature did not establish any safeguards for minors other than those provided for adults.

In particular, unlike the police custody regime for minors, it did not provide for the judicial police officer to inform the parents, the guardian or the person or service to whom the minor has been entrusted, nor for mandatory assistance by a lawyer, etc.

The Cour de cassation therefore held that it was for the Constitutional Council (Conseil constitutionnel) to determine whether the safeguards afforded to a minor in a voluntary interview are sufficient in the light of the fundamental principle of a specific, protective criminal law for minors that takes account of their vulnerability.

In its decision of 8 February 2019, the Constitutional Council struck down this article.

The Council noted that, under the contested provisions, the arrangements for a voluntary interview are identical when the person questioned is a minor, whatever their age.

The Council therefore considered that, as they stand, the provisions of Article 61-1 are not sufficient to ensure that the minor gives informed consent to the voluntary interview, nor to prevent them from making choices contrary to their interests.

Accordingly, the Constitutional Council found that the legislature had breached the fundamental principle recognised by the laws of the Republic in the field of juvenile justice.

It concluded that the contested provisions must be repealed, and deferred the repeal to 1 January 2020. Immediate repeal would have had excessive consequences, as it would have removed the legal safeguards governing all voluntary interviews, for adults and minors alike.

The ball is now in the legislature's court: it must urgently introduce specific safeguards for the voluntary interviews of minors.

One to watch…

Recent publications